In practice, vaadat kabala (ועדת קבלה, admission committee) is used for two different processes. One is the admission committee under the Cooperative Societies Ordinance, which governs the allocation of residential plots and the transfer of rights in community settlements and expansions, only where the law applies. The other is the approval of a buyer of a nahala (נחלה, an agricultural family holding) by the moshav's cooperative association (agudah), under its bylaws. Correct as of November 2026.
How does acceptance by the association for a nahala differ from the admission committee for an expansion plot?
When a nahala is bought, the Israel Land Authority (RMI) approves a transfer of rights only to a buyer the association has approved in writing. The basis is the decisions of the Israel Land Council and the association's bylaws, not the Admission Committees Law.
For a plot or a house in a harchava (הרחבה, a residential expansion of a moshav), the question is whether the community falls within the Ordinance's definition of a community settlement (yishuv kehilati). If it does, allocating the plot and transferring rights in it require an admission committee's approval. If it does not, none is required, and under the Council's decisions RMI markets the expansion plots by tender.
What is the legal basis for admission committees?
The basis is the Law to Amend the Cooperative Societies Ordinance (No. 8), 5771-2011, known as the Admission Committees Law. It was passed by the Knesset on 22 March 2011, published on 30 March 2011 and came into force 30 days later, adding sections 6B to 6D to the Ordinance. In HCJ 2311/11 Sabach v. Knesset (judgment of 17 September 2014) the petitions against the law were dismissed by five justices to four; President Grunis held that the constitutional questions were not ripe for decision.
Amendment No. 12, passed on 25 July 2023 and published on 30 July 2023, widened the arrangement:
- A national-priority community was added to the definition of a community settlement, alongside the Galilee and the Negev.
- A continuing community settlement was added: a community of up to 700 housing units approved by the Committee for Community Settlements.
Which communities does the law apply to?
Under section 2 of the Ordinance, a community settlement is a community in the Galilee, in the Negev or a national-priority community, organised as a cooperative society that the Registrar of Cooperative Societies has classified as a rural community settlement or as a cooperative society for community settlement, or an expansion of a kibbutz, a moshav shitufi, a moshav ovdim or a kfar shitufi organised as such a society. The number of housing units in the community, or in the original community and the expansion together, does not exceed 400.
The Supreme Court and RMI's guidance document for admission committees, both from before the 2023 amendment, read the location requirement as a cumulative condition that also applies to expansions. On that reading, an expansion of a moshav that is not in the Galilee, the Negev or a national-priority community is not a community settlement for the law's purposes.
What may an admission committee consider, and what may it not?
Under section 6C of the Ordinance, the committee may refuse a candidate only on one or more of these grounds:
- The candidate is a minor.
- The candidate lacks the financial ability to build a home in the community within the period set in the land allocation agreement.
- The candidate does not intend to make the community the centre of his or her life.
- The candidate is not suited to social life in a community, based on a professional opinion from an expert in assessing such suitability.
- A lack of fit with the community's social and cultural fabric that there is reason to believe would harm it.
- Unique characteristics of the community, or admission conditions in the association's bylaws, approved by the Registrar.
The committee may not refuse a candidate on grounds of race, religion, sex, nationality, disability, personal status, age, parenthood, sexual orientation, country of origin, opinion or political party affiliation.
How does the process work, and how is a decision challenged?
The committee has five members, including representatives of the community, the regional council, the movement the community is affiliated with, and the Jewish Agency or the World Zionist Organization. The chair is the regional council's representative, who is not a resident of the community.
A candidate who is refused receives a reasoned decision. The candidate and the community may file an objection with the appeals committee (vaadat hasagot), whose members are appointed by the Minister of Construction and Housing. Under the working procedures on RMI's website (updated 15 January 2026), the objection is filed within 30 days of receiving the decision, and the appeals committee decides within 60 days of completing the objection proceedings. Its decision can be challenged by petition to the Court for Administrative Affairs.
A transfer of rights by inheritance does not require an admission committee's approval. The sale of an existing house in a community the law applies to requires the committee's approval of the buyer.
How is a buyer of a nahala accepted by the association?
Under the Cooperative Societies (Membership) Regulations, an application for membership is made as laid down in the association's bylaws, and admission follows them. A person who is refused may appeal to the general meeting, unless the bylaws name another body.
For RMI, the association's refusal is not always final: in exceptional cases RMI may transfer the rights in the nahala without the association's consent, if it considers that the refusal rests on unreasonable grounds and after the association has had an opportunity to explain.
How do candidates usually prepare?
RMI's guidance document describes the stages of the process before an admission committee: getting acquainted with the community, an assessment at a professional institute by interview, questionnaire or group exercise, and a committee hearing at which the candidate is given an opportunity to respond to every claim. Because the financial ability to build a home and the intention to make the community the centre of one's life are two of the grounds for refusal, these are the matters candidates are asked to show.
What was confirmed and what was not
Confirmed against the text of the law, the judgment and RMI's publications: the scope of the law, the grounds for refusal, the composition of the committee and the time limits for objections. Not confirmed: which communities in the Sharon and Emek Hefer, if any, fall within the law; what each association requires from buyers in practice; and how long the processes take.




